Strand Manufacturing Co., Inc.


Home
Grinder
Chill-Rolls
Conveyor-Kibbler
Contact Us


 

The Strand Mill

"Laboratory Preparation of Powder Coatings"

Introduction

Laboratory development time is critical to any industry. Therefore, to maximize the effort the best tools need to be used. In the development of powder coatings, there are many pieces of equipment that have been developed to reproduce large scale production. Included in this equipment are various laboratory grinders used in an attempt to match the particle size distribution achievable with an ACM (air classifying mill), common to most powder production lines. however, none of these devices have been found to be as effective, low cost, or efficient as the Strand Mill portable table top grinder. This review will compare the efficiency, ease of use, and ultimate particle size achievable with some of the common pieces of equipment used in the laboratory preparation of powder coatings.

Types of Mills used to match a production ACM mill

The most common pieces of equipment used in the laboratory preparation of powder coatings including the following: coffee grinder, Vitamix, Brinkman, Bantam, and a bench top ACM mill. This equipment ranges in price from $25 for a coffee grinder up to $30,000 for a bench top ACM. A simple coffee grinder consists of fixed blades, a small stainless bowl, and a plastic top. It is limited in capacity, inefficient, and includes plastic parts which cannot be solvent cleaned. Overall, contamination and durability is poor. Another common grinder is stainless steel Vitamix. A Vitamix is no more than a high speed blender, It' odd shaped container with corners, and small blade to height ratio is very inefficient for grinding dry powders. A more expensive option is a Brinkman SR3 mill. This mill grinds with a hammer tooth ring and a classifying screen. The product is ground by the hammers until it is small enough to pass through the screen. These mills are very difficult to clean and generate a lot of heat which frequently fuses the powder. Another choice is a Bantam mill. In principle, the Bantam mill works much like the Brinkman mill, however, it comes with a liquid nitrogen accessory which enables cooling during grinding. The Bantam contains many parts, is difficult to clean, and is not practical for fast evaluations or small samples. The final option is a bench top ACM mill known as the ACM-1. In principle an ACM-1 duplicates the mechanics of a production ACM mill. Although production particle size can be matched, cooling is a problem, it is not difficult to clean, and settings do not always coincide with production equipment.

Equipment

Cost($)

Efficiency
(Yield)

Ease of
Cleaning

Particle
Size

  Coffee Grinder

  25-100

  20-30%

  Poor

 Too Coarse

  Vitamix

  350-450

  20-40%

  Excellent

 Too Coarse

  Strand Mill

  1,300-1900

  40-50%

  Excellent

 Slightly Coarse

  Brinkman

  13-14,000

  70-90%

  Poor

 Too Coarse

  Bantam

  20,000+

  80-90%

  Poor

 Too Coarse

  ACM-1

  25,000+

  75-95%

  Poor

 Excellent

What is the Strand Mill

Non of the above options enables the fast, efficient, cost effective, preparation of laboratory samples of powder coatings. However, now there is a solution, The Strand Mill. The Strand Mill is a unique portable table top grinder that can quickly reduce flake into powder in less than 10 seconds. The mill consists of a motor housing, stainless steel bowl, two blades, and a stainless screw on top. The key to the Strand Mill is the construction of the blades and the geometry of the container which creates a unique mixing action. With this unit, it is possible to grind up to about 150 grams of flake at a time. Cleanup is easy, and it has been found to most accurately duplicate the particle size distribution of a production ACM mill. No other laboratory piece of equipment can match the easy of use, efficiency, and results of the Strand Mill.

Particle Size Comparison

In order to compare the performance of the Strand Mill with the other equipment, a standard 50/50 polyester epoxy hybrid was extruded using a Buss PLK-46. The sample was split and ground on the five different pieces of laboratory equipment. All samples were then sieved using a 140 mesh screen, and analyzed for particle size using a Coulter LS-130. The following table is an overlay of the particle size distributions for each piece of equipment.

 Equipment

Partical Size 

 Coffee Grinder

 200 microns
 Vitamix 190 microns
 Strand Mill 170 microns
 Brinkman 170 microns
 Bantam 170 microns
 AMC production 160 microns

Note: It was assumed that the laboratory ACM-1 could match the ACM production particle size and there it was not run. Comparing the other pieces of equipment it can be seen that the Strand Mill comes close to duplicating an ACM production mill. The following table compares approximate costs, efficiency, ease of cleaning, and particle size for each unit.

STRAND MILL (LAB GRINDER) COMPARISONS
     SMALL LAB GRINDER      MODEL # S101DS
        Bowl Capacity - 150 Grams           

    LARGE LAB GRINDER          MODEL# S102DS      
        Bowl Capacity - 350 Grams           

S101DS 2S102DS pg2

110 volt     10 amps                                    110 volt    15amps

1200W      25,000 RPM                              1800W      25,000 RPM

Small verses Large Strand Grinding Comparison

 
Starting Material
Replicate

d(.1)

 d(.5) d(.9)

1

153.3900

 

393.5000

 

561.37

2

147.0700

 

383.2500

 

559.53

3

156.8100

 

397.5800

 

562.22

average

152.4233

 

391.4433

 

561.04

      
Small Strand Grind

d(.1)

 d(.5) d(.9)

time

D(v,0.1) S

time

D(v,0.5) S

time

D(v,0.9) S

0

152.4233

 

391.4433

 

561.04

4

96.1600

 

304.9900

 

534.32

8

74.9900

 

266.2400

 

514.69

16

65.0700

 

256.6300

 

508.70

      
Large Strand Grind

d(.1)

 d(.5) d(.9)

time

D(v,0.1) L

time

D(v,0.5) L

time

D(v,0.9) S

0

152.4233

 

391.4433

 

561.04

4

102.5700

 

316.4700

 

537.04

8

79.2200

 

275.7400

 

516.24

16

53.5500

 

216.0900

 

473.52

STRAND LAB GRINDER
Replacement Parts List

Model S101DS

 

Model S102DS

 P/N               ITEM

Price US $ 

 P/N              ITEM

Price US $

DS101-01  Nut/Lockwasher

$8.65 

DS102-01  Nut/Lockwasher

$9.15

DS101-02  Blades Set
              (1 upper, 1 lower)

$43.25
 

DS102-02  Blades Set   
              (1 upper, 1 lower)

$44.75

DS101-03  Dust Cover

$17.75 

DS102-03  Dust Cover

$18.50

DS101-04  Bearing, Upper

$7.95 

DS102-04  Bearing, Upper

$7.95

DS101-05  Brush Set

$11.40 

DS102-05  Brush Set 

$11.40

DS101-06  Motor
DS101-07  Bowl/Lid

Call 

DS102-06  Motor
DS102-07  Bowl/Lid

Call

DS101-09  Bearing, Lower

$7.95 

DS102-09  Bearing, Lower

$7.95

DS101-10  Felt Washer, (2)

$3.50 

DS102-10  Felt Washer, (2)

$3.50

DS101-13  Cap, Brush

$3.50 

DS102-13  Cap, Brush

$3.50

DS102-15  Switch

$19.50 

DS102-15  Switch

$19.50

*Call For Additional Pricing

 

*Call For Additional Pricing


| Home | Grinder | Chill-Rolls | Conveyor-Kibbler | Contact Us |

Strand Manufacturing Co., Inc.   1515 5th Street South #C   Hopkins, MN 55343
Phone: 952-935-8699   Fax: 952-935-8799   Email: jlkolb@strandmfgco.com
Copyright © 2007 - Strand Manufacturing Co., Inc. - All Rights Reserved